Religious but not spiritual: The high costs of ignoring personal piety

Men would rather watch Monday Night Football than go shopping. Eating too many Hardees Monster Thickburgers is linked to obesity. Texting while driving is a bad idea.

There are times when research findings are so obvious they are almost beyond questioning. So it is puzzling that growing evidence showing the importance of congregations cultivating the spiritual lives of the faithful is so routinely ignored.

Puzzling, and damaging to the health of many of the nation’s churches, especially those most in need of revival.

Even though research shows  spiritually alive churches are the most likely to grow, the percentage of U.S. congregations reporting high spiritual vitality declined from 43 percent in 2005 to 28 percent in 2010, according to the latest Faith Communities Today survey.

The drop was accompanied by a decline in the emphasis given to spiritual practices such as prayer and scripture reading across nearly all groups aside from white evangelicals and congregations with 1,000 or more attenders.

The most notable slide occurred among white mainline Protestant denominations, which have been aging and losing members faster than any other major religious group.

The reasons are varied: Declining financial health in the recession saps morale; aging memberships are less likely to embrace new forms of worship; some denominations have shifted emphasis away from personal piety toward social service programs.

It’s not, however, because they don’t know any better.

Spiritual and religious

Study after study shows what may appear to outside observers to be simple common sense: A major reason people attend religious congregations is to deepen their faith lives and draw closer to God.

The U.S. Congregational Life Survey found the percentage of weekly worshippers who reported growing in faith through their congregation was twice as high as the percentage of more infrequent attenders who experienced similar spiritual growth.

The survey also indicated that “grassroots evangelists,” those who feel at ease sharing their faith with others and invite people to worship, were far more likely to strongly agree their spiritual needs are being met in the congregation and to practice devotional activities every day or most days.

“Worshippers in strong congregations also regularly spend time on their own praying, reading Scripture or using other materials to help them better understand and deepen their faith,” survey researchers reported. “In other words, congregations where people spend time on their own cultivating their faith tend to have extraordinary worship as well. They’re bookend strengths.”

In a survey of megachurches, the No. 1 reason people gave for moving from a spectator to an active participant in their congregation was this:  “I responded to an inward sense of call or spiritual prompting,” researchers Scott Thumma of Hartford Seminary and Warren Bird of the Leadership Network reported in their new book, “The Other 80 Percent: Turning Your Church’s Spectators Into Active Participants.”

And the No. 1 reason people participated less in their congregation in the past two years?  It was a tie between “had less time” and their faith had “gotten weaker,” according to a separate survey of parish profile inventories offered by the Hartford Institute for Religion Research.

“Surveys of church people clearly indicate an important reality about people who are highly committed: The most involved are the most likely to say they are spiritually fulfilled, to acknowledge spiritual growth and to express satisfaction with their journey of faith. There is a strong, unmistakable relationship between the two,” Thumma and Bird wrote.

Even the hardest to reach groups in the contemporary religious marketplace —  young adults — appear open to approaches emphasizing spiritual growth.

Researchers Christian Smith and Patricia Snell of the University of Notre Dame examined results from the National Study of Youth and Religion in their book “Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults.” They found factors that do predict high levels of commitment include frequent prayer and Scripture reading, personal religious experiences and highly religious parents.

Yet spiritual sustenance is often what people both young and old are not getting from their congregations.

The gap widens

In 2000, about three quarters of white mainline congregations from denominations such as the Episcopal Church and the United Church of Christ reported giving a great deal of emphasis to spiritual practices. By 2010, less than two-thirds, or 63 percent, emphasized practices like prayer and scripture reading, according to the Faith Communities Today survey,

By comparison, the percentage of white evangelical congregations giving a great deal of emphasis to spiritual practices rose slightly, from 90 percent to 91 percent.

It is difficult for many congregations today to remain spiritually vital amid  decreasing financial health as a result of  the recession and shrinking worship attendance in a time when religious observance is more of a choice than an obligation.

The loss of morale creates an environment where many say: “It doesn’t feel as if God is in this place,” said David Roozen, a lead researcher of the Faith Communities Today survey.

But part of the issue is also the choices many church leaders have made to place greater emphasis on social service programs or church committee work than on promoting spiritual growth.

There is evidence that going back to the 1960s and 1970s many mainline Protestant leaders “took faith for granted” while emphasizing other programs, Roozen said.

But activities such as prayer, worship and scripture reading are integral to the faith of people of all ages, researchers say.

“If they’re going to go (to church), why they want to be there, I think, is for religion,” Roozen said. “They want to connect with God and a community that connects with God.”

The mystery is why that is so hard to understand.

 

Subscribe to Ahead of the Trend via email, RSS or social media.


5 Responses to “Religious but not spiritual: The high costs of ignoring personal piety”

  1. I hope that his article is seen by the various denominational magazines. I think especially of those in my church (PCUSA) such as Presbyterians Today and the independent journal, Presbyterian Outlook.

  2. [...] TweetAmong other things, churches without a spiritual vitality are reporting declining numbers.Details:Men would rather watch Monday Night Football than go shopping. Eating too many Hardees Monster [...]

  3. [...] The reasons are varied: Declining financial health in the recession saps morale; aging memberships are less likely to embrace new forms of worship; some denominations have shifted emphasis away from personal piety toward social service programs….Read this in full at http://blogs.thearda.com/trend/featured/religious-but-not-spiritual-the-high-costs-of-ignoring-perso... [...]

  4. [...] The reasons are varied: Declining financial health in the recession saps morale; aging memberships are less likely to embrace new forms of worship; some denominations have shifted emphasis away from personal piety toward social service programs….Read this in full at http://blogs.thearda.com/trend/featured/religious-but-not-spiritual-the-high-costs-of-ignoring-perso... [...]

  5. Pearlette says:

    Good article and right on point. Every vibrant congregation offers some type of formation that strengthens personal peity (e.g. bible study). People should not have to decide between bible study and social service activity, both should be offer and attended by the participants of both. You just can’t be Christ-like if you are not grounded in Christ.

Leave a Reply

Search Ahead of the Trend

Please type your search term:

Archive Categories
Most Recent Columns
ARDA Affiliate
Primers & Tutorials
Connect with the ARDA

Our Most Popular Tags

Click on your desired tag, to view the available columns.

  • US Congregational Membership Reports

    Explore congregational membership in every county, state, and urban area in the United States. Based on the Religious Congregations and Membership Study collected by the Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies this is the most complete census available on religious congregations and their members.

    Enter your 5-digit zip code to see a
    religious profile now:
     

    National Profiles

    ARDA's National Profiles provide detailed data by country on religious adherents, religious freedom, demographics and a host of other social measures. Choose a country below to see its profile:

    US Denominations

    Our American Denominations feature provides detailed information and family trees for over 400 U.S. religious denominations.

    QuickStats

    Use QuickStats to browse dozens of topics and see reponses from major national surveys, demographic patterns, and changes over time! Available topics:

    QuickLists

    Use QuickLists to see rank-ordered data on religion in the U.S. and around the world. See our most popular topics:

    ...or browse through many more by visiting QuickLists.