The Final Four, travel teams and empty pews: Research on sports and religion

The Rev. Stephen Fichter understood just how dominant a role sports has assumed in the culture when a family told him they would be out of town Good Friday to Easter Sunday to attend their child’s volleyball tournament.

“It’s truly sports that has become like the religion” for many people, said Fichter, a researcher and the pastor of Sacred Heart Church in Haworth, N.J.

From youth travel teams to big-time national festivals such as the Final Four, sports have been making increasing inroads in the busy lives of many Americans. Some scholars even trace the evolution of sports from pastime to a form of civil religion to now having become almost a folk religion.

And it is having an impact on religious groups, which report increasing difficulty convincing families that are willing to spend half a day traveling to a 9-year-old’s softball or soccer game to make time for worship services.

Some congregations are meeting the challenge by offering alternative service times and their own sports teams and programs. But many despair of their ability to compete in a culture increasingly consumed by athletics, with its multi-million dollar idols and its own sacred relics. Witness the Babe Ruth jersey that sold last year for $4.4 million.

In a study of 16 declining congregations in the U.S. and Canada, the reason most cited by clergy and members for falling attendance was the secularization of Sunday, with many identifying children’s sports as most responsible. Researcher Stephen McMullin of Acadia Divinity College in Nova Scotia reported the findings in the current issue of the Review of Religious Research.

“(Parents) will make sure Johnny goes to sports, but when it comes to church, I’ve just seen it over and over again, and even in our own congregation, the families that have children in sport will sacrifice church for the sake of their son or daughter’s sports program, so sports is another huge reason why our church is declining,” one pastor said.

A sporting life

There were few Easter Christians, individuals who show up for worship one or two days a year, among the earliest followers of the faith.

Facing penalties “like hanging — that tends to clear the head,” the Rev. Aidan Kavanagh, the late liturgy professor at Yale Divinity School, dryly observed.

Christians in the United States no longer need fear persecution for missing services. Demanding schedules, many of which revolve around youth sports, are the new competition for congregations.

Fichter surveyed 341 Catholics in one congregation who reported attending only on Easter and Christmas. He said he thought many people would cite disagreement with church teachings or negative experiences. But only 7 percent of respondents gave either of those reasons.

More than two-thirds said the reason they attend only twice a year was that they were too busy with other commitments. Sixteen percent admitted they were lazy. Fichter reported the findings at the joint annual meeting of the Society for the Scientific Study of Religion and the Religious Research Association.

The 2008 Faith Communities Today survey looked at obstacles to regular participation in church, including driving distance, fear of crime and work schedule conflicts. But school- and sports-related activities — true for urban, suburban and rural congregations – were the biggest challenges. More than a third of congregations said it was somewhat or quite a bit of an issue.

The scope of the problem seemed to overwhelm many of the 16 declining congregations in McMullin’s study.

“In focus group after focus group, members considered how they might make changes that would attract new people and invariably concluded that nothing could be done,” he wrote in the Review of Religious Research.

Congregations that blame their own ills on society and parents who miss church for organized sports had another negative outcome: Families whose children are involved in sports stop attending, McMullin said.

But other congregations are meeting the challenge in new ways.

If you can’t beat ’em …

One response has been to add services at alternative times such as Saturday and Sunday evenings to provide more opportunities for parents and children to attend both sporting events and church.

What also has seemed to be helpful is for churches to offer their own sports programming.

Research has shown congregations that offer multiple opportunities for members to participate in church life are more likely to experience growth.
Offering sports programs “is a point of entry,” said David Roozen, director of the Hartford Institute for Religion Research. “Often the biggest competition is for young families with kids.”

Some 36 percent of congregations in the 2010 Faith Communities Today survey, including more than four in 10 evangelical Protestant congregations, reported at least some emphasis on team sports, fitness activities and exercise classes.

“Evangelicals are much more aware that they really have a competing worldview with the secular world,” Roozen said.

And the combination seems to have its benefits. More than two-thirds of congregations who said sports and fitness programs were a specialty of the congregation reported more than a 10 percent growth in attendance from 2000 to 2010. In contrast, only a third of churches with no athletic programs reported such growth.

Survive and advance is one mantra of teams in the NCAA basketball tournament culminating in the Final Four. One idea for churches struggling in a sports-obsessed culture may be a similar strategy: Adapt and advance.

3 Responses to “The Final Four, travel teams and empty pews: Research on sports and religion”

  1. Jim Ferry says:

    I speak as a still recovering parent of big time travel ball – softball in our case, with my daughter playing in numerous national tournaments. Among her dreams was the possibility of a college scholarship – then she got hurt – then she was shunned and in effect run off the team to make room for “better” players. This hurt her deeply. It hurt me. Looking back on it all, I now realize that time she spent away from youth group and the church denied her needed spiritual resources to deal with this heartbreak. I have come to see how cut-throat dog eat dog travel team athletics vastly fails to deliver on its implied promises of imparting character and preparing our young people to cope with life. To the contrary, it so often exposes them to life’s hard-knocks at a much too young and tender age. And now, as a pastor, I have a family in the church I currently serve with the same dream my daughter used to have. They have been drifting away – even though I have made it a point to keep in touch and even, if briefly, attend some of her games. Then last fall as part of a stewardship sermon I happened to mention that giving our children the gift of faith and giving them to the Lord is the best and most important thing parents can ever do for their children – this, more important than anything else, even sports – even the arts. It just so happened that this family was present that Sunday. They haven’t been back since. I’m trying to think what to do next.

  2. I fought our sons baseball coach on this when he was young – he would be late to practice on Sundays because he was going to church. AAU basketball may be the worst offenders – how many “Easter Classics” were held all over the country?

    Sports is now an idol in America – it’s become a God, and it’s destroying the young spiritual lives of a generation.

    “You shall have no other gods before me.”

    Father, forgive us, for we know not what we do…

  3. Momofsportskids says:

    While I agree that travel sports are over-the-top, please remember that parents have little control over the schedules. In some areas, travel soccer games are played on Sundays. Why not rec you ask? Because our rec league stinks (ie mixing 6-8th graders) since everyone wants to play travel. The travel league IS more organized, gets better field time, and provides better and safer training. (ie Rec practices 8-9:30pm on a bumpy field in the dark with a dad who didn’t play soccer coaching 12-14yos!).

    My son loves the sport and just wants to play with his friends…and he wants to play in HS. We don’t have much of a choice with schedule – it’s up to the league and soccer club. Luckily, we’ve been blessed with good coaches and league managers. (One year, we had a terrible coach and it was awful!! the league fired him though after listening to complaints).

    Not all of us are religious people….different families/parents have different needs and expectations. Sunday is not a sacred time for everyone.

    This is a tough one. I think focusing on what is age-appropriate is best for all, and ensuring coaches have proper training, and providing opportunity for all players (ie, if everyone doesnt make the HS team, are there other opportunities to play? not everywhere!).

Leave a Reply