
U.S. clergy may be increasing the sting of death for many members of their flocks.
Two new studies find that many clergy are both ill-prepared and reluctant to fully engage in end-of-life conversations with terminally ill congregation members and their families.
The result, both studies suggest, is that more believers may be spending their final days enduring painful treatments with little chance of success in intensive care units rather than receiving comfort care at home.
One of the studies was a national survey of more than 1,000 clergy. The other involved in-depth interviews with 35 ministers from five states. The research raises three critical areas of concern:
• Too much faith in miracles: More than three in 10 clergy in the national survey said they would strongly agree with a congregant who said, “I believe God will cure me of this cancer.” Eighteen percent affirmed the belief that every medical treatment should be accepted “because my faith says to do everything I can to stay alive.”
• Lack of knowledge: In the in-depth study, spiritual leaders showed little knowledge of end-of-life care, including the benefits of palliative care and potential harms associated with invasive interventions. “Many grossly overestimated the benefits of aggressive medical procedures at the end of life,” researchers reported in the Journal of Palliative Medicine. Three-quarters said they would like more training in end-of-life issues.
• Fear of overstepping boundaries: The default position of many clergy, even those who personally believed it was against God’s will to suffer unnecessarily, was to merely support the decisions of dying congregants and their family members.
But even such passivity has consequences, researchers said, in that it can enable congregants to seek potentially nonbeneficial treatments that are associated with increased suffering.
The larger problem was summarized by one study participant: “We have not done a good job…on preparing people to die–that they don’t need to live the last days of their lives under terrible and excruciating pain.”
Competing principles
The new studies are part of The National Clergy Project on End-of-Life Care.
What is clear in both studies is the complexity in end-of-life decision making.
Spiritual principles such as the sacredness of life and the capacity for divine healing may come into conflict with other religious principles to comfort the suffering and place faith that God will care for individuals after this life.
For example, clergy were asked in the national study what they would talk about when visiting a patient with cancer and no hope for a cure.
Fifty-six percent said it is important to encourage acceptance of dying as part of God’s plan. Two-thirds would place a priority on suggesting hospice as a good idea. Eighty percent said it is important to talk about heaven and life after death.
Yet, 60 percent also would strongly encourage prayer for physical healing, holding out hope for a miracle.
At one extreme, 18 percent of clergy endorsed the idea of accepting every medical treatment to prolong life, and 16 percent said doctors and nurses should do everything possible to extend the life of a patient.
The clergy most likely to place their faith in divine healing were from the black church, Pentecostal and evangelical traditions and those serving low-income congregations, researchers stated in the Journal of Pain and Symptom Management.
The attitudes mattered to their flocks.
Clergy who endorsed life-prolonging religious values were approximately half as likely as other clergy to have a discussion concerning entering hospice, stopping treatment or forgoing treatment. The absence of a clergy-congregant hospice discussion was associated with less hospice and more ICU care.
In the in-depth interviews, no clergyperson said aggressive care was an “absolute good.” Several said it hampered a good death, and one said it was an “absolute bad,” researchers reported.
Yet despite their own strong views, many clergy refrained from influencing decisions about end-of-life care.
The ministers said they did not offer guidance out of respect for the “free will” of congregants, but researchers indicated a lack of knowledge of the medical consequences also played a role.
Humble approach
What can be done to assist clergy in helping religious individuals make better informed decisions about end-of-life care?
Clergy education is critical, researchers from both studies said.
The studies concluded that clergy training focused on the intersection of religious values and medical issues at the end of life offer several opportunities for improving care, including:
• Closing the gap between the clergy’s beliefs and actions.
• Empowering clergy to counsel congregants about the moral and spiritual implications of end-of-life medical decisions.
• Supporting religiously informed decision making by patients that minimizes unnecessary physical and spiritual suffering.
• Creating partnerships of ministers and disease-based and palliative care clinicians.
What clergy say – and what they do not say – can make a major difference in whether believers experience a “good death,” the studies find.
“There are times,” one black minister from Chicago told researchers, “Death itself is a cure to what ails you. It’s the healing.’’
Image by Mark Makowiecki, via Wikimedia Commons (Public Domain)
Image from Bundesarchiv, B 145 Bild-F010160-0001 / Steiner, Egon / CC BY-SA 3.0
3 Responses to “Studies: How clergy can help believers die a 'good death'”
Leave a Reply
Please type your search term:
- abortion
- aging
- animals
- atheist
- Baby Boomers
- Bible
- biology
- Buddhist
- Catholic
- Christianity
- congregations
- disability
- diversity
- earthquake
- economics
- education
- environment
- ethics
- evangelical
- evolution
- Faith
- family
- Forgiveness
- freedom
- gambling
- genetics
- giving
- God
- Government
- health
- hell
- Hindu
- history
- humility
- immigration
- international
- Internet
- Islam
- Judaism
- law
- mainline
- marriage
- Methodist
- millennials
- Mormon
- music
- nones
- Orthodox
- Paranormal
- parenting
- Pentecostal
- Politics
- poverty
- prayer
- race
- science
- secular
- sexuality
- shopping
- sin
- singles
- spirituality
- sports
- Uncategorized
- violence
- virtue
- women
- worship
- youth
- Study: Girls raised by Jewish parents outperform Christian girls academically
May 16th, 2022 - Even abortion foes will help friends who choose to end a pregnancy
May 9th, 2022 - How America’s youth lost its religion in 1990s
April 13th, 2022 - Study: Women of no faith face discrimination — when they are seen at all
March 22nd, 2022
Primers
- The Many Faces of Islam By John L. Esposito
- Religious Freedom and Conflict A Review of the Evidence By Roger Finke and Robert R. Martin
Tutorials
Click on your desired tag, to view the available columns.
anxiety
Baylor Religion Survey
Bible
Catholic
Christianity
clergy
compassion
congregations
depression
diversity
Donald Trump
evangelical
evangelicals
Faith
fear
Forgiveness
gender
God
health
humility
immigration
Islam
kindness
love
mainline Protestant
marriage
mental health
millennials
nones
politics
Pope Francis
poverty
prayer
prejudice
race
religion and health
religion and politics
religious freedom
secular
self-esteem
sexuality
social support
spirituality
stress
worship abortion (9)
aging (24)
animals (4)
atheist (37)
Baby Boomers (7)
Bible (63)
biology (7)
Buddhist (17)
Catholic (64)
Christianity (160)
clergy (55)
congregations (14)
disability (4)
diversity (28)
earthquake (2)
economics (60)
education (31)
environment (8)
ethics (59)
evangelical (73)
evolution (6)
Faith (222)
family (38)
Featured (253)
Forgiveness (15)
freedom (48)
gambling (2)
genetics (4)
giving (10)
God (126)
Government (45)
health (91)
hell (1)
Hindu (12)
history (24)
humility (21)
immigration (19)
international (41)
Internet (8)
Islam (41)
Judaism (20)
law (6)
mainline (48)
marriage (12)
Methodist (4)
millennials (11)
Mormon (6)
music (5)
nones (17)
Orthodox (1)
Paranormal (2)
parenting (9)
Pentecostal (4)
Politics (53)
poverty (22)
prayer (32)
race (27)
science (43)
secular (46)
sexuality (24)
shopping (3)
sin (6)
singles (1)
spirituality (78)
sports (5)
Uncategorized (43)
violence (24)
virtue (11)
women (45)
worship (68)
youth (66)
WP Cumulus Flash tag cloud by Roy Tanck and Luke Morton requires Flash Player 9 or better.
Explore congregational membership in every county, state, and urban area in the United States. Based on the Religious Congregations and Membership Study collected by the Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies this is the most complete census available on religious congregations and their members.
ARDA's National Profiles provide detailed data by country on religious adherents, religious freedom, demographics and a host of other social measures. Choose a country below to see its profile:
Our American Denominations feature provides detailed information and family trees for over 400 U.S. religious denominations.
Use QuickStats to browse dozens of topics and see reponses from major national surveys, demographic patterns, and changes over time! Available topics:
Use QuickLists to see rank-ordered data on religion in the U.S. and around the world. See our most popular topics:
[…] — can make a major difference in whether believers experience a ‘good death,'” the Association of Religion Data Archives reported in its overview of recent […]
[…] Two recent national studies suggest that clergy find these conversations about the end of life decisions to be challenging. The researchers conclude that those individuals who are guided through these periods of health crisis by miracle-hoping, life-affirming, faithful clergy are more likely to increase the cost of their medical care. This is compared to the lower cost of those whose spiritual beliefs are honored by and supported primarily by medical staff. You may read more about this research here. […]
[…] an article for The Association of Religion Data Archives, David Briggs summarizes the findings of two recent studies on faith and end-of-life treatment. The studies suggest that “many clergy […]